Toastee Bagels | Jersey-Style Bites & Brews in Plains Twp.
Toastee Bagels in Plains Township, PA is a locally owned bagel shop serving breakfast and lunch with authentic Jersey-style flavor. Bagels are handcrafted and baked fresh in-house every day, giving each visit that warm, just-out-of-the-oven feel. It’s a reliable stop for early mornings, quick lunches and post-practice refueling.
The menu starts with more than 16 bagel varieties. Choices range from classic plain and everything to asiago, jalapeño cheddar, blueberry and rotating seasonal options. Each bagel can be paired with a hot cup of coffee or espresso drink, or enjoyed alongside a fresh pastry like muffins, crumb cake or brownies.
Sandwiches are made to satisfy. Breakfast options feature hearty combinations like egg and cheese, steak egg and cheese and pork roll and cheese. Lunch brings hot favorites like cheesesteak and buffalo chicken, along with cold deli-style sandwiches and filling salads.
Menu Highlights
Cream cheese spreads add another layer of flavor, with 13 varieties including strawberry, scallion, lox, chocolate chip, cinnamon honey butter and peanut butter and jelly. Breakfast sandwiches are made hot and filling, while lunch selections balance bold flavors with comfort classics. Coffee lovers can choose from brewed coffee, lattes, cappuccinos, espresso, iced coffee, hot tea and hot chocolate. Catering options make it easy to feed a crowd, offering bagel boxes, platters, breakfast spreads, lunch trays and Joe to Go.
Community involvement is part of the shop’s daily routine. Leftover bagels are donated to local food banks and churches, helping neighbors across the region.
Toastee Bagels in Plains Township delivers fresh bagels, satisfying meals and a strong sense of local pride.
