Skip to Main Content Jump to Main Content
Hero Background Dots

Casually delicious Italian American cuisine

Valley Pizza and Subs has been a Sugarloaf Valley staple for over 30 years. The mom and pop pizzeria welcomes the Sybertsville community into its family daily by serving favorite Italian American dishes. The huge pizza menu ensures everyone will find something they enjoy. And with plenty of other options, including wings, salads, and subs, no one will leave hungry.

Menu Highlights

Valley Pizza and Subs offers a wide variety of pizza favorites. If you want to get experimental, the Taco Pizza is an interesting take on two classic dishes. For sandwich lovers, the Valley Special sub is the way to go. It comes with ham, turkey, American cheese, and mayo. And if you’re looking to share, Valley Pizza’s wings, with plenty of sauce options, are perfect for the whole family.