NEPA’s Local Bakeries Bring Homemade Thanksgiving Pies to the Dessert Table
From classic pumpkin and apple to rich pecan and other seasonal favorites, bakeries throughout NEPA are serving up homemade goodness straight from the oven. Each Thanksgiving pie is made with care—flaky crusts, flavorful fillings, and plenty of local pride baked right in.
Across NEPA, talented bakers are mixing up tradition and creativity to make sure every slice tastes like home. Whether you’re ordering from a small-town café, a beloved neighborhood bakery, or a local restaurant known for its desserts, you’ll find no shortage of sweet options to make your holiday meal extra special. Just remember to order ahead—most of these delicious Thanksgiving pies are made to order and tend to sell out fast!
Plains, PA
Bakery Delite in Plains is a local favorite for perfectly baked Thanksgiving pies. Their seasonal creations are known for balanced flavors and buttery crusts that keep customers coming back year after year. Place your order early to ensure you don’t miss out.
Must Try: Classic Pumpkin Pie
Learn More
Carbondale, PA
Barbour’s Bakery in Carbondale has been baking homemade pies since 1912. Their classic fruit and cream pies are made the old-fashioned way, with fresh ingredients and no preservatives. Each slice captures the warmth and nostalgia of a true hometown bakery — perfect for Thanksgiving dessert.
Must Try: Apple Crumb Pie
Learn More
Honesdale, PA
Be Kind Bake House in Honesdale bakes scratch-made pies with flavors that rotate based on what’s fresh. Look for seasonal Thanksgiving favorites and occasional vegan or gluten-free options, announced on their social channels.
Must Try: Bourbon Peach Crumb
Learn More
Kingsley, PA
Bingham’s Restaurant in Kingsley is famous for homemade pies that taste just like grandma used to make. From coconut cream and cherry to rich pecan, each pie is baked from scratch and served fresh daily. Bingham’s pies are the perfect ending to any Thanksgiving meal.
Must Try: Caramel Apple Crumb Pie
Learn More
Dallas, PA
Head to Brace’s Orchard in Dallas, a seventh-generation family farm known for its fresh fruit and homemade baked goods. Their farm market is filled with seasonal favorites like apple, cherry, and peach pies, all made with fruit grown right on the property. Brace’s pies bringing a true taste of NEPA tradition to your holiday table.
Must Try: Strawberry Rhubarb
Learn More
Shavertown, PA
Cakes by Imelda Filip, LLC in Shavertown makes delicious made-to-order pies. From classic pumpkin to apple, each pie is baked fresh with a tender crust and rich, flavorful filling. Be sure to preorder for the holiday season.
Must Try: Classic Pumpkin Pie
Learn More
Hazleton, PA
Carmen’s Bakery & Deli in Hazleton is known for its homemade holiday pies that bring a taste of tradition to every table. Each pie is baked fresh with flaky crusts and flavorful fillings, perfect for Thanksgiving gatherings.
Must Try: Cherry Pie
Learn More
Throop, PA
Gino’s Bistro and Bar in Throop offers gourmet takes on Thanksgiving classics like apple and pumpkin pie. Each dessert combines the restaurant’s culinary creativity with traditional holiday comfort. Be sure to reserve yours in advance.
Must Try: Peanut Butter Pie
Learn More
Dallas, PA
Jane’s Sugar Magnolia in Dallas bakes beautiful, homemade pies that bring warmth and sweetness to any Thanksgiving table. Their handcrafted crusts and flavorful fillings make every slice a celebration of the season.
Must Try: Pecan Pie
Learn More
Scranton, PA
Lynn Sandy’s in Scranton is known for its delicious variety of Thanksgiving pies, from apple crumb to classic pumpkin. Each pie is baked to perfection with plenty of hometown flavor. Order early—these local favorites sell out fast.
Must Try: Lemon Cream Pie
Learn More
Scranton, PA
Minooka Pastry Shop in Scranton has been baking pies and pastries for over 40 years. Their Thanksgiving pies—like apple, pumpkin, and pecan—are made with care and classic flavor in every bite. Order your holiday favorites before they’re gone.
Must Try: Chocolate Cream Pie
Learn More
Scranton, PA
National Pastry Bake Shop in Scranton makes large, traditional pies perfect for holiday gatherings. Their beloved Pumpkin Squares offer a single-serve twist on their signature pie, perfect for sampling before Thanksgiving Day.
Must Try: Blueberry Crumb Pie
Learn More
Kingston, PA
Something Special in Kingston creates homemade pies that live up to their name. Each one is baked with care and filled with comforting, seasonal flavors that make Thanksgiving dessert unforgettable.
Must Try: Maple Walnut Pie
Learn More
Stroudsburg, PA
Stroudsmour Bakery and Café in Stroudsburg crafts fresh, homemade pies using quality ingredients and family recipes. Their Thanksgiving selection includes traditional favorites like apple and pumpkin, baked daily for peak freshness.
Must Try: Pumpkin Apple Crumb Pie
Learn More
Delaware Water Gap, PA
The Village Farmer and Bakery in Delaware Water Gap has been baking homemade pies since 1976. Their Thanksgiving pies are a Pocono Mountain’s tradition, made from scratch with flaky crusts and rich, flavorful fillings.
Must Try: Fruit of the Forest Pie
Learn More
Scranton, PA
Zummo’s Café in Scranton pairs cozy coffeehouse vibes with freshly baked Thanksgiving pies. Their homemade selections are the perfect complement to a hot cup of coffee and a holiday gathering with friends and family.
Must Try: Classic Pecan Pie
Learn MorePlace Those Pie Orders Today
Whether you’re craving a classic pumpkin pie, a rich pecan pie, or something a little unexpected, these NEPA bakeries have you covered. Each one brings its own local flavor, family tradition, and homemade touch to the holiday table. So, place your orders early, gather your loved ones, and let these sweet creations make your Thanksgiving just a little bit sweeter.
Load Up That Holiday Dessert Table
Article updated from its original version published on 11/16/24.
