Peppe’s Pizza & Subs | New York flavor & NEPA tradition in Plains
Peppe’s Pizza & Subs in Plains brings the best of Brooklyn-style pizza to the Wyoming Valley while keeping true to classic NEPA tastes. This family-friendly pizzeria is known for its crisp, thin-crust New York pies topped with rich, balanced sauce and gooey cheese. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or ordering for family dinner, Peppe’s delivers big flavor in every bite.
Guests rave about the sweet sauce that perfectly complements the slightly caramelized cheese and golden-brown crust. In addition to round pizzas, Peppe’s also serves Old Forge–style trays that showcase their local roots. The menu features much more than pizza—customers can enjoy hot and cold subs, like the Chicken Parmigiana or classic Italian, along with salads, wings, mozzarella sticks, and homemade soups.
Peppe’s offers a small dine-in area with a welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit feel like home. Many locals stop in for takeout or take advantage of convenient delivery throughout the Plains area. Each pizza is crafted with care, using fresh ingredients and traditional techniques that have earned Peppe’s a loyal following over the years.
Peppe’s Pizza & Subs in Plains delivers authentic New York–style pizza, warm hospitality, and timeless neighborhood pizzeria charm.
