Mary Lou’s Pizza | Classic Trays & Family Recipes in Old Forge
Mary Lou’s Pizza in Old Forge, PA has been serving up homemade trays of classic Old Forge-style pizza since 2001. This family-owned pizzeria has earned a loyal following by sticking to the recipes that made the town famous for its signature square pizza. Whether you’re dining in or taking your tray to go, Mary Lou’s delivers consistent quality, bold flavor and that unmistakable Old Forge charm.
Inside, the dining space is stylish but simple, offering a cozy spot to enjoy your favorite tray fresh from the oven. Everything is made in-house, from the pizza dough to the pasta and bread. Mary Lou’s takes pride in tradition, and it shows in every bite. Locals love the friendly service, the casual vibe and the consistently delicious pizza that keeps them coming back year after year.
Menu Highlights
At Mary Lou’s, it’s all about the red and the white. The red tray features a soft, airy crust, tangy tomato sauce and a generous layer of gooey cheese. The double crust white tray is a customer favorite, known for its golden, pillowy top and rich, savory flavor. Standouts also include the shrimp pizza, hot pepper pizza and seasonal fresh tomato tray. Popular toppings like broccoli, spinach, sausage, mushrooms and peppers round out a menu built for loyal pizza lovers.
Mary Lou’s Pizza in Old Forge keeps tradition alive with homemade trays, classic flavors and time-tested family recipes.
