Cusumano | Modern Italian Cuisine & Bold Flavors in Old Forge
Cusumano in Old Forge offers a modern take on Italian dining while honoring the town’s iconic pizza tradition. This contemporary restaurant reimagines Italian and American favorites with bold flavors, premium ingredients and creative flair. While known for its refined pasta and meat dishes, Cusumano also celebrates Old Forge pizza with a menu that’s always ready to impress. Diners can enjoy classic red and white trays, fresh tomato pies, savory Grandma-style pizza, and specialty options like shrimp or hot broccoli white trays.
Inside, the atmosphere blends warmth with style, creating a perfect spot for a date night, group dinner or casual meal. The culinary team focuses on signature sauces, handmade pasta and thoughtful details, offering gluten-free substitutions to meet dietary needs. Guests appreciate Cusumano’s ability to elevate familiar flavors while keeping the experience welcoming and approachable.
Menu Highlights
The pizza menu is a standout, featuring traditional red and white trays, a fresh tomato option and unique specialties like shrimp and hot broccoli. Other favorites include wild boar ragu over pappardelle, house-made manicotti and creative takes on regional dishes like pagach. Each plate or tray reflects passion and innovation, giving diners a taste of tradition with a twist.
Cusumano in Old Forge blends inventive Italian cuisine with Old Forge pizza classics, delivering a dining experience that’s memorable and delicious.
Cusumano
