Old Mill Pizzeria | Family recipes & crowd favorites in Sciota
Old Mill Pizzeria in Sciota is a family-owned restaurant serving fresh, comforting Italian and Greek-inspired dishes for more than 20 years. The pizzeria is known for hot, cheesy pies, hearty pasta dishes, flavorful gyros and an impressive menu that stretches far beyond pizza alone. Guests stop in after Little League games, grab takeout on busy nights or book the private dining room for gatherings of up to 40 people. The team prepares every dish with care, using family recipes and fresh ingredients to create a warm, welcoming dining experience. With subs, salads, wraps, seafood, specialty pizzas and even ice cream and milkshakes, the menu offers something for every craving.
Old Mill Pizzeria balances classic Italian comfort with a fun, casual atmosphere that keeps locals returning year after year. Regulars enjoy the large portions, helpful staff and consistent quality across an expansive menu. Whether guests want a quick slice, a full dinner or a place to celebrate with friends, the pizzeria delivers dependable flavor and friendly service.
Menu Highlights
Popular choices range from cheese steaks and garlic knots to stuffed chicken bacon ranch pizza and creamy Fettuccine Alfredo. Calzones, antipasto salads, gyros and classic plain pizza slices remain guest favorites for both dine-in and takeout.
Old Mill Pizzeria in Sciota delivers generous plates, friendly service and comforting Italian classics made with family tradition.
