Cara Mia’s Delicatessen | Award-Winning Mozzarella & Gourmet Italian Fare in Dunmore

Cara Mia’s Delicatessen in Dunmore brings three generations of Italian cheese-making tradition to the table with every bite. Built on an 80-year-old family recipe for fresh mozzarella passed down from Cara Mia’s grandfather in Italy, this upscale Italian deli is beloved for its signature cheese, gourmet subs, fresh salads, and artisan pizzas. Whether you’re grabbing lunch or ordering catering for an event, Cara Mia’s offers bold flavors and handcrafted quality in every dish.

Menu Highlights

Their award-winning menu has earned accolades for Best Lunch, Best Vodka Sauce, Best Deli, and Best Hoagie—and it’s easy to see why. The Cara Mia Classic sandwich is a standout, featuring marinated roasted red peppers, homemade fresh mozzarella, spinach, and pesto mayo on a hoagie roll. Other popular choices include their personal pizzas and entrée salads, each elevated by that creamy, house-made mozzarella.

In addition to heartier options, Cara Mia’s offers lighter fare like their customer-favorite chicken noodle soup—perfect for a cozy, comforting meal. For parties and gatherings, catering services are available with 48 hours’ notice for hot food and 24 hours’ notice for cold platters.

Cara Mia’s Delicatessen combines family tradition, fresh mozzarella, and gourmet Italian favorites for a delicious experience in Dunmore.