Derff’s Pizza | Crave-Worthy Classics in Sugar Notch
Derff’s Pizza in Sugar Notch is a hometown staple where tradition, family, and flavor come together. Proudly family-owned and operated, this hidden gem has built a loyal following over the years thanks to its dedication to consistent taste, friendly service, and old-school pizza shop charm. Whether you’ve been visiting for decades or are stopping by for the first time, you can always expect pies that are crispy, crunchy, and completely crave-worthy.
What makes Derff’s stand out is its range of styles. Fans can order classic round pies with thin, crispy crusts, hearty Sicilian-style squares, or Old Forge-inspired trays—all prepared with the family’s time-tested recipe. Each option pays homage to the region’s pizza traditions while adding the Derff’s touch that customers love. With an array of toppings, every pie can be personalized, but regulars swear by the extra cheese, mushroom, and signature sweet sauce combinations.
Menu Highlights
The Sicilian-style pizza is one of Derff’s biggest draws. Unlike many versions, it’s thick yet light and airy, with a texture that customers describe as almost “fried” from the oven—a unique spin that sets it apart. Another standout is the pagash pizza, a nod to the area’s Polish heritage. Traditionally an Easter dish, this potato- and cheese-topped creation has become a year-round favorite that blends comfort food with cultural tradition.
Derff’s Pizza in Sugar Notch has earned its place as a local favorite, offering crave-worthy pies that keep customers coming back for more.
