Local Bakeries & Cafés Serving Homemade Pie in Northeastern PA
Homemade pie remains a favorite dessert across NEPA, and local bakeries and restaurants keep the tradition alive year-round. From flaky fruit pies filled with apples, blueberries and cherries to rich cream pies like coconut, banana and chocolate, Northeastern PA offers plenty of places to enjoy a classic slice.
Many neighborhood bakeries rely on time-tested recipes and buttery crusts that have been part of the community for generations. Others add creative flavors and seasonal ingredients that bring something new to the pie case. Whether stopping in for dessert after dinner, grabbing a slice with coffee or ordering a whole pie for a holiday gathering, local bakeries across NEPA make homemade pies easy to find.
These favorite spots serve everything from traditional favorites to specialty pies that showcase the region’s love for fresh-baked desserts.
Plains, PA
Bakery Delite in Plains bakes homemade pies with flaky crusts and classic fillings that keep customers returning to this longtime neighborhood bakery. Their rotating selection often features traditional fruit pies and seasonal favorites prepared fresh in-house.
Must Try: Pumpkin Pie
Learn More
Carbondale, PA
Barbour’s Bakery in Carbondale has been baking classic homemade pies using traditional recipes since 1912. Their selection includes fruit and cream favorites like apple, blueberry, cherry and lemon meringue, all made the old-fashioned way.
Must Try: Coconut Cream Pie
Learn More
Honesdale, PA
Be Kind Bake House in Honesdale prepares scratch-made pies with creative flavor combinations and seasonal ingredients. Their rotating lineup includes varieties like blueberry lavender cream, cherry almond crumb and chocolate pecan.
Must Try: Blueberry Lavender Cream Pie
Learn More
Beach Lake, PA
Beach Lake Bakery in Beach Lake bakes homemade pies in small batches alongside its artisan breads and European pastries. Their rotating selection includes fruit favorites like apple, cherry and wild blueberry alongside rich options like pecan and Mississippi Mud.
Must Try: Wild Blueberry Crumb Pie
Learn More
Kingsley, PA
Bingham’s Restaurant in Kingsley is well known for its extensive lineup of homemade pies served fresh daily. Classic fruit pies and rich cream varieties like banana cream, coconut cream and chocolate peanut butter make dessert a highlight of any visit.
Must Try: Blackberry Crumb Pie
Learn More
Dallas, PA
Brace’s Orchard in Dallas bakes fruit-filled pies using produce grown right on the family farm. Apple, cherry, peach and berry pies are available with crumb or traditional crust toppings, along with favorites like strawberry rhubarb and coconut custard.
Must Try: Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Learn More
Shavertown, PA
Cakes by Imelda Filip in Shavertown prepares made-to-order pies with traditional flavors and carefully baked crusts. Classic varieties like apple and pumpkin appear seasonally and are often reserved for holiday gatherings and special orders.
Must Try: Pumpkin Pie
Learn More
Hazleton, PA
Carmen’s Bakery & Deli in Hazleton bakes homemade pies featuring generous fillings and traditional flavors. Their menu includes standout varieties like strawberry pie, lemon meringue and a towering Mile High Apple pie weighing more than five pounds.
Must Try: Mile High Apple Pie
Learn More
Throop, PA
Gino’s Bistro and Bar in Throop creates specialty dessert pies that add a creative twist to classic favorites. Unique flavors like cannoli pie, peanut butter bliss and caramel apple crunch appear as seasonal dessert offerings.
Must Try: Cannoli Pie
Learn More
Dallas, PA
Jane’s Sugar Magnolia in Dallas bakes elegant pies featuring classic holiday flavors and carefully crafted crusts. Favorites like pumpkin, pecan and apple crisp appear as seasonal specialties from this charming bakery.
Must Try: Pecan Pie
Learn More
Scranton, PA
Lynn Sandy’s Bakery in Scranton prepares a wide selection of classic fruit and cream pies in its well-stocked bakery case. Favorites include blueberry crumble, banana cream, coconut cream, key lime and rich peanut butter pie.
Must Try: Peanut Butter Pie
Learn More
Scranton, PA
Minooka Pastry Shop in Scranton has been baking traditional homemade pies for generations at its longtime neighborhood bakery. Their lineup includes fruit pies like apple and blueberry alongside cream favorites like chocolate, coconut and peanut butter.
Must Try: Chocolate Cream Pie
Learn More
Scranton, PA
National Pastry Bake Shop in Scranton offers a variety of classic fruit and cream pies made fresh in its longtime kosher bakery. Crumb-topped blueberry, cherry and apple pies share the spotlight with banana, chocolate and coconut cream varieties.
Must Try: Lemon Chiffon Cream Pie
Learn More
Kingston, PA
Something Special in Kingston bakes homemade pies filled with classic fruit and specialty flavors. Favorites include apple, peach, triple berry, pecan, key lime and a rich chocolate peanut butter pie.
Must Try: Peach Pie
Learn More
Stroudsburg, PA
Stroudsmoor Bakery & Café in Stroudsburg prepares traditional fruit and cream pies alongside seasonal specialties throughout the year. Popular varieties include apple walnut, coconut custard, fruit of the forest and pumpkin apple crumb.
Must Try: Fruit of the Forest Pie
Learn More
Delaware Water Gap, PA
Village Farmer and Bakery in Delaware Water Gap bakes dozens of homemade pies with flavors that rotate throughout the year. Their extensive selection ranges from fruit pies like cherry, blueberry and peach to classics like shoofly, sweet potato and coconut custard.
Must Try: Red Raspberry Crumb
Learn MoreOrder Ahead for Homemade Pies from NEPA’s Bakeries & Cafés
Many NEPA bakeries recommend ordering ahead if you plan to bring home a whole pie. Some keep a few pies in the case for slices or same-day purchases, but full pies, especially cream pies and specialty varieties, are often baked to order.
Classic fruit pies like apple, blueberry and cherry tend to be available most of the year, while richer varieties like banana cream, coconut cream, key lime and peanut butter often appear in limited batches. Seasonal favorites rotate throughout the year as well, from strawberry rhubarb in spring to pumpkin and sweet potato in fall.
Whether you’re picking up dessert for a family dinner, a holiday gathering or simply bringing home a slice to enjoy with coffee, these NEPA bakeries make it easy to find a homemade pie worth sharing.
Load Up That Holiday Dessert Table
Article updated from its original version published on 11/16/24.
5 Places for Pie in NEPA
